This is no holy war

But first, a funny story. Mistakes that local, but non-military, kids make in this Northern Virginia area:

While driving on Route 395 through Arlington, Neighbor Girl looks over and sees a very large building. “Is that that hexagon building?” she asks.

Pentagon…hexagon…same thing.

Pentagon Briefings No Longer Quote the Bible

The Pentagon said Monday it no longer includes a Bible quote on the cover page of daily intelligence briefings it sends to the White House as was practice (sic) during the Bush administration.

Whatever. I don’t really care if the cover page that nobody really reads has a Bible quote or not.

What gets me going is the Rev. Barry W. Lynn, executive director of Americans United for Separation of Church and State, suggesting that a Bible quote on a Pentagon brief portrays American soldiers as crusaders.

Let me tell you, the military is the one place where we do not want to remove God. The military, like the rest of America, is worldly, secular, and materialistic. There are pockets of religiously-minded people, but they run the gamut of all religions, and include varying degrees of devotion to that religion. And, just like the rest of America, there are many, among those who are “devout,” who “homechurch” or otherwise worship in their own manner, like seeing the beauty of God in a quiet golf course on a Sunday morning.

There is no lock-step, no single-mindedness, no communal belief in a higher calling.

And when you’re talking about “boots on the ground” soldiers, the ones actively engaging the potential enemy, you have a population that is mostly under 25. Like the rest of America, this age group is the least likely to consider themselves devout anything.

As uncomfortable as this concept may be for the average civilian, a soldier’s primary job is to defend and protect, which is a really nice way of saying kill. They are not a police force, designed to capture bad guys and bring them to a court system for justice. Although most (the old and the wise) soldiers hope that by carrying guns and looking tough, the bad guys will decide to pick on easier targets – like Europe – they all know that their job description includes “eliminating” threats.

Do we want a godless Army?

Do we want soldiers who don’t believe that there are any eternal consequences for their behavior on the battlefield or off? What, then, will keep them from crossing the line from killing during a battle to murdering anything that crosses their line of sight? We expect soldiers to make split second decisions – is that a combatant hiding in the closet or a little child? I have a hard time believing that fear of prosecution is a greater motivator to make the right choice than fear of eternal damnation, especially if your fellow soldiers and commanding officer and entire chain of command are equally unconcerned about morality. For at some point, the thought of “getting away with it” will permeate the organization if there aren’t any Jiminy Crickets in the bunch.

Bill’s job is hard and there are many long hours. In many ways it is incompatible with the family-centered lifestyle we desire, and the sacrifices required by the children and I are tremendous. He certainly isn’t in it for the money, and even if he were, the risk – and the fear – of sending a husband and father off to war and getting back a body in a box or a broken and changed man does not at times seem worth it. Dying does not bother my husband nearly as much as the thought of leaving behind a widow and six orphans to cope with the mess their lives suddenly became. And leaving that possibility aside, there are only so many baseball games or ballet recitals that you can miss before you start to doubt that this is the right career path.

But the military needs family men who can see their own child’s eyes reflected in those of a scrawny kid in Kosovo. It needs men who derive comfort from, as well as fear, a just God who reads the hearts of all and knows the truth of what you do. A moral man does not obey an unlawful order. Take God out of the military and you risk creating a power unfettered by conscience.

So, again, whatever. No more Bible quotes on Pentagon briefs. But may the civilians whose sensibilities are so disturbed at the thought of soldiers deriving comfort and direction from the Word of God hold their own behavior and choices to such a supreme standard.

10 thoughts on “This is no holy war

  1. Talk about “Posts” – this one ought to go to the Washington one. What a clear, succinct, powerful comeback. You ought to at least send it to the offending Rev. – but I think it deserves a wider audience.

    Wow! you can write!

  2. To quote Ernie Pyle “There are no athiests in foxholes.”

  3. So, I ordered some business cards with my contact info on it and I decided to put a quote on it. I was down to two and I was leaning towards this one from A-Log (that is Abe Lincoln’s gangsta name): “America will never be destroyed from the outside. If we falter and lose our freedoms, it will be because we destroyed ourselves.” It will be those most staunchly defending our rights who will eventually have us lose them. I ended up with G-Cat (Chesterton’s gangsta name): “If I can put one touch of rosy sunset into the life of any man or woman, I shall feel that I have worked with God.” Maybe instead of a Bible quote, they can use Chesterton. He rocks!

  4. Great post, Michelle!

    You beat me to the quote, Bill.

  5. I get a lump in my throat when I think about the changes being made by the current administration. The thought of a Godless society <>freaks me out,<> Michelle, and yet…and I know this is no good…I feel rather helpless to change it.

    Perhaps that is what Satan’s legions want.

  6. This is an EXCELLENT post. I agree with Mom R.

  7. You sing it Sister! I wish I could say it that well.

  8. Wow. Just wow. You said it all, and said it all perfectly.

  9. Thank you. You said that very well.

  10. You make an excellent point here, Michelle.

    Thank you for the sacrifices you, your husband, and children make for our country.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s